Gardner takes the oldest story in english literature of a hero defeating a monster and turns it on its head by seeing the tale through the eyes of the monster grendel. Jan 26, 2021 reading the poem beowulf, many ideas, related to the forces of good fighting those of evil, are present within its structure and within its events. The novel deals with finding meaning in the world, the power of literature and myth, and the nature of good and evil. The battle between beowulf and grendel is an intense scene and begins when grendel attempts to devour beowulf. Beowulf is a story from the viewpoint of the danes and favors them in their story, but in grendef it is in favor of the young monster named grendel.
Beowulf held grendel s ripped arm up high in prideful victory. The tone between beowulf and grendel differ in perception, righteousness, and. Beowulf usually tries to make things better though. Just swap out one monster for another, one battleground for another, and you have pretty much the same story. Lastly all the characters in beowulf the story are flat characters meaning that they are not so much human and dont change feelings a lot.
The original story explained more about the aftermath of the fight. Mar 01, 2008 beowulf corners grendel in heorot, a large mead hall, and rips off his arm. Beowulf tells a story that proves otherwise and gains hrothgars blessing to fight grendel. Sep 28, 2020 all jokes aside, i had always wondered what a civil conversation between grendel and beowulf would have looked like. After ruling the danes for fifty years, a dragon attacks the town. A short story from the epic english poem beowulf the nowell codex unknown on. Tales of grendel s evil spread across the sea and reached the ears of a young warrior prince named beowulf. Though he has many animal attributes and a grotesque, monstrous appearance, he seems to be guided by vaguely human emotions and impulses, and he shows more of an interior life than one might expect.
John gardners book, grendel, is written in first person. One of the reasons of why the book beowulf is so well known is because of the fact that it is one of the first stories of good vs. Grendels point of view in beowulf as the perfect hero. The book narrates the story on a norse hero and warrior known as beowulf. Good and evil is one of the main conflicts in the poem beowulf. So, we see even though both grendel as well as beowulf depict the same character of the monster grendel, they both do them in each their different perspectives. Purge herot and your ship will sail home with its treasureholds full. Grendel is a 1971 novel by american author john gardner. The movie beowulf and grendel and the beowulf book had many similarities and differences such as the added characters to the movie that were not included in the book. My story had grendel s arm ripped from his body and that is what happened in the original story. But a close look at the story reveals the rarely told tale of grendel, who despite dishonor and pain still fights to right the wrongs done to him and his ancestors.
Beowulf found and fought in the mountains, in a dark, muggy cave. Beowulf sails to denmark to help hrothgar and his people in their battle with the. In beowulf, it is almost universally accepted that beowulf is the hero meant to defeat the villain, grendel. The th warrior has many, many, many similarities and differences when compared to the original epic poem, beowulf. Aug 29, 2008 beowulf beowulf is the longest and greatest surviving anglosaxon poem. Grendel one of the most compelling and highly developed characters in the novel grendel, written by john gardner, and the poem beowulf, written by an anonymous poet, is the monster, grendel. The main character in this story is beowulf who stands for all that is good in a epic battle against grendel, the monster, who represents evil, death, and pure darkness. Grendel, an outsider who spurns society, and beowulf, an outsider who joins the danes in fellowship, battle. In anticipation, the danes gradually slip away to their hiding places, but not before giving beowulf and his men soft blankets and pillows. Beowulf ends up with a son, that he has no knowledge of, with grendel s mother. There are quite a lot of changes in plot of the poem, and the sequence of things in the film.
In this paper i will talk about the similarities and differences between the two stories, beowulf, which is a book about a mighty hero that sets out to slay monsters and grendel, which is the. As this was going on, beowulf saw grendels fighting skills and knew exactly how to approach him to win. In this paper i will talk about the similarities and differences between the two stories, beowulf, which is a book about a mighty hero that sets out to slay monsters. The fight scene between beowulf and the grendel both take place in a mead hall. Gardners grendel, on the other hand, is a retelling of the beowulf story through the. In the story of beowulf, not the movie, grendel is a monster similar to that of a troll or ogre. The monster in the story of beowulf being grendel s mother and the lair in the ocean being her lair in the lake. In the movie grendel attacked beowulf in the heriot while. When beowulf fought grendels mom, he got her sword and. That night, grendel attacks beowulf and his men while they sleep in hrothgars great hall, killing the geat who desecrated his fathers head and then, revenge satisfied, leaps out from the second story, but is caught in a trap by beowulf, leaving grendel hanging by his right arm. This song speaks of a monster that lives in a lair in the ocean. The meeting between hygelac and beowulf marks the end of the first part of the poem. Beowulf beowulf first page of beowulf in cotton vitellius a.
Similarities and differences between beowulf and grendel. The roles that beowulf and grendel played in the story were very easily deciphered. The geats and the danes enjoy a feast in heorot, fully knowing that grendel will eventually show up. A comparison of beowulf and grendel 947 words 123 help me. My source described that they posted up grendel s arm for everyone to see. Oct 06, 2020 the battle between beowulf and grendel is an intense scene and begins when grendel attempts to devour beowulf. Beowulf s battle with grendel serves as beowulf s first great, heroic achievement in the poem. Monsters and heroes in beowulf the british library.
Grendel explores the power, consequences, seductions, and deceptions of various forms of language. Beowulf the part where he fights grendel rewritten by me. John gardner transforms the perceived terrible evil fiend who is grendel into a lonely but intelligent outcast who bears a striking resemblance to his human adversaries. The book translated by burton raffel, beowulf, is written in third person. He is described as having above human strength, is quick but does not necessarily put up a big fight. John gardner transforms grendel, once perceived as an evil fiend in beowulf, into a lonely but intelligent outcast who is actually quite similar to humans, due to his. Grendel becomes frightened, but beowulfs hold is too strong for grendel to escape.
This statement shows that both beowulf and grendel have the same settings. That story is the epic beowulf, which many still read today. Beowulf against grendel beowulf kneeled in front of king hrothgar. Grendel in beowulf, grendel is seen as a villain because he goes around causing. Beowulfs reputation for bravery precedes him and, while he boasts, some even suggest that he is too brave, or foolishly brave. Keep it free of evil, fight 390 wit glorh y in your heart. This theme is followed in both the novel as well as the poem. His ability to speak marks him as different from the rest of the natural world that cannot respond to him. He then made up a detailed story of how he had followed the beast to his underwater lair and destroyed him in a fight that lasted all night. As the story begins, hrothgars men are conducting their nightly ritual of feasting, boasting and drinking until they pass out in the main hall. The anglosaxon story of beowulf told in 3 short animated episodes for ks2 pupils. Beowulf idealism and materialism contrasts old english epic vs. He describes the proposed peace settlement, in which hrothgar will give his hygelac rewards beowulf for his bravery with land, swords, and houses. Similarities and differences between beowulf and grendel cram.
Comparison of beowulf and grendel free essay example. Differences between beowulf book vs movie page 1 compare. Beowulf then has to combat grendel s mother, who wants revenge. In beowulf and grendel, grigsby applies archaeology, philology, and comparative mythology to a study of the origins of the beowulf story. In beowulf the story beowulf also fights sea monsters with a giant sword when he goes to fight the grendel s mother.
Beowulf and grendel book and film essay example for. He also finds grendel s dead body, cuts off the head, and returns to land, where the geat and danish warriors are waiting expectantly. Both novels are based on the idea of beowulf killing grendel. Beowulf, however, is wakeful, eager to meet his enemy. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Beowulf is an epic poem about the honesty, bravery, and humility that defined the ideal.
Beowulf is burned when he does and a tower monument is build in remembrance. The monster, grendel, is not a creature of mythic powers, but one of flesh and blood immense flesh and raging blood, driven by a vengeance from being wronged, while beowulf, a victorious soldier in his own right, has become increasingly troubled by the heromyth rising up around his exploits. Comparing beowulf and the th warrior book vs movie. Exiled to the swamplands outside the boundaries of human society, grendel is an outcast who seems to long to be reinstated. I based most of my story on the actual fight scene. The story he told them was of a great monster, who took men into the swamp to devour them, purely for fun. Grendel the folks own fastness that fiery dragon with flame had destroyed and the stronghold all washed by waves. And this causes grendel to become fearful of beowulf. Point of view in grendel and beowulf essay on beowulf. Grendel becomes frightened, but beowulf s hold is too strong for grendel to escape.
Beowulf is strong and brave and he has been called to kill grendel. Language is what separates grendel from nature and from his mother. At the end of both stories beowulfs cousin wiglaf receives the throne for his bravery. They share setting and tell of the exact same events, but beowulf and grendel have two entirely different themes. The most striking thing about grendel is that the novel is narrated by a monster. Grendel, refusing capture, escapes by hacking off his own arm. Is it just a cheap way to stretch out the storyline and have more thrills. What are the men doing when beowulf arrives at the hall. After defeating the dragon, he learns that it was his son. The epic story of beowulf is about a young hero who fights in battles against the monster grendel and his mother and later concerns beowulfs final fight with a.
Beowulf and his warriors were lying in my mead hall as night approached. Grendel, a trolllike monster said to be descended from the biblical cain, is pained by the sounds of joy. Beowulf is the oldest surviving epic in english literature. Gardner tells the epic tale of beowulf through the eyes of grendel, one of the three monsters that beowulf battles in the original poem.
This idea is never more evident than through the disparity between burton raffels translation of beowulf and john gardners grendel. Beowulf grapples grendel, who has a chain wrapped around his arm, pulling it loose. Both have 3 encounters off monsters the grendel, the grendels mother and the dragon. John gardner in his book, grendel set out to change the readers perception of grendel and his role in beowulf by narrating the story through grendel s point of view. Beowulf kept a stron hold on the monster however, until there was a sharp sound of ripping tendons and muscles, and a crushing of bones. The king looked down kindly but the expression on his face was somber, for grendel had devoured thirty of his best thanes the prior night. Apr 24, 20 as for the battle between grendel s mother and beowulf i think that the song the devil and the deep dark ocean by nightwish is a good choice.
The first main point is when beowulf kills grendel. The story takes place around the sixth century in northern europe. Even though beowulf, grendel, and grendel mother come across as evil, they do have attributes to positive things in the story and try to be pleasant. In short, beowulf likes a good fight, and everyone knows it. Beowulf being pure good, and grendel being pure evil. Likely the poems most memorable creation, grendel is one of the three monsters that beowulf battles.
By lineage, grendel is a member of cains clan, whom the creator had outlawed and condemned as outcasts. Beowulf kills grendel mother because after grendel is killed, grendel s mother attacks heorot in revenge. It is a retelling of part of the old english poem beowulf from the perspective of the antagonist, grendel. Although grendel s feelings are portrayed as remorseful and the reader gives more sympathy towards his actions, he is still committing the same crimes in both readings. Beowulf suddenly grabs grendel by the arm and tightens his grip when the monster.
His soldiers are sure they will not see their country again. After a terrible fight, beowulf kills the monster with a magical sword, probably put there by the alweilder, that he finds on the wall of her home. Modern day film in the story of beowulf, heaney which takes place in ad, the protagonist beowulf is a geat hero who fights monsters and is known as the strongest conqueror around. The very language that enables grendel to tell his own story actually isolates him within what grendel calls a pale skin. Aug 12, 2020 structurally, beowulfs fight with grendels mother mirrors his fight with grendel. To do so he dives into the depths of a dreadful lake. Beowulf begins with the story of hrothgar, who constructed the great hall, heorot, for himself and his warriors. The events may be the same, but the tone in which the story is told shapes the readers understanding of the events. The characters that were used in the movie were presented in different aspects, with different motives, appearances, and names. Jun 07, 2019 in beowulf, it is almost universally accepted that beowulf is the hero meant to defeat the villain, grendel.
Aug 06, 2020 beowulf tells a story that proves otherwise and gains hrothgars blessing to fight grendel. Check out our revolutionary sidebyside summary and analysis. Compare and contrast beowulf and grendel 979 words. The beowulf comparecontrast from the story to the video. The main characters in the story are beowulf, grendel, hrothgar, and grendel s mother. When he heard the story of grendel, he vowed he would cross the sea and deliver hrothgar from his enemy, for beowulf feared no one. It was written in 1970s, and is set in the fourth century a. Its a bit of a stretch, but i think it exposes the other side of these characters. In the book beowulf translated by burton raffel, there are three main points that are important to the plot. Grendel is envious, resentful, and angry toward mankind, possibly because he. The same goes for the movie, with beowulf cutting off grendel s arm in a fight. The novel thus continually asks what it means to be a monster and how monsters and humans differ.
Beowulf makes good on his boast that he will fight grendel singlehanded. John gardner in his book, grendel, sets out to change the readers perception of grendel and his role in beowulf by narrating the story through grendel s point of view. Despite the story s clear bias to beowulf as the hero his name is the title of the story after all, upon closer inspection it becomes clear that in the norse tradition, the true tragic hero is grendel. Hearing of hroogars plight and grendel s laying siege on heorot, beowulf travels to heorot to defeat. In it, he, his wife wealhtheow, and his warriors spend their time singing and celebrating. But were only a third of the way into the poem, and. It is the spinoff of beowulf, and tells the story of grendel, one of the monsters in the epic beowulf. Grendels mother, beowulf tells king hygelac about the feud between denmark and their enemies, the heathobards. Even though these pieces show two different sides to grendel they are similar in many ways. The second main point in the story is when beowulf kills grendel s mother.
Oct 06, 2015 the main characters in the story are beowulf, grendel, hrothgar, and grendel s mother. Beowulf, and the dragon and beowulf, which are the main events in the book. Although the battle is furious, beowulf has won as soon as he is able to grasp his. Differences and similarities between grendel and beowulf. This skit or whatever youd like to call it was written to take place of the fight between beowulf and grendel. As grendel is trying to flee heorot, beowulf slams the door on his arm, severing it. The last main point in the story is the death of beowulf. In beowulfs bloody battle against grendel, the first part of the story reaches its. As depicted in beowulf, compare beowulf s fight with grendel with his fight with grendel s mother in order to determine which seems more dangerous. The first battle was between beowulf and grendel, but beowulf never used. Beowulf cuts off grendel s arm while he is fighting him in the book.
275 2 979 265 1146 357 748 266 302 740 1570 853 696 1049 461 1318 427 995 1431 47 1443 218 733 1309 41 1266 1002